How to improve gross margin: a COGS teardown

Free assessment

See if PILTA can help. A free 15-minute call with the PILTA Founder and CEO Ryan or one of our expert executives and strategists.

A company improves gross margin with four levers: raise the price it actually collects, shift the mix toward higher-margin products and channels, lower COGS (cost of goods sold), and stop leakage such as unapproved discounts, unrecovered freight, returns and write-offs. All four start with the same step: knowing the true cost and margin of every SKU (stock keeping unit) in every channel.

This guide works as a teardown. It breaks unit cost into its parts, lists where savings usually come from on each line, then covers manufacturing, price, mix and leakage, and ends with a 90-day plan.

Quick definitions

Gross margin: Revenue minus COGS, divided by revenue, shown as a percentage.

COGS (cost of goods sold): The cost of the products sold in a period: materials, production labor, packaging that is part of the product, freight-in and production overhead.

Landed cost: The full cost of getting a unit into the warehouse: factory price plus freight, duties, insurance and handling.

Should-cost model: An estimate of what a part or product ought to cost, built up from materials, labor, overhead and supplier margin, used to test quotes.

The gross margin formula and its four levers

Gross margin is revenue minus COGS, divided by revenue. It shows how much of each sales dollar is left to pay for selling, marketing, overhead and profit. Four levers move it:

  • Price. What the company actually collects after discounts, allowances and promotions.
  • Mix. The share of sales that comes from higher-margin products, customers and channels.
  • Cost of goods. Materials, components, packaging, production labor, freight-in, duties and production overhead.
  • Leakage. Money lost between list price and cash in the bank: returns, deductions, unrecovered freight, scrap and write-offs.

Price carries the most weight per point. In McKinsey’s 2003 analysis of the average S&P 1500 company, a 1 percent price increase with steady volume raised operating profit by 8 percent, nearly 50 percent more than a 1 percent cut in variable costs such as materials and direct labor.

Cost work still matters. Customers and retailers do not accept every price increase, and a lower unit cost applies to every unit the company sells from then on.

Step 1: Build the true unit cost by SKU

A blended gross margin on the P&L (profit and loss statement) can look healthy while some SKUs lose money once freight, packaging and channel costs are counted. The teardown rebuilds the cost of each SKU from its parts.

Start with what the IRS counts in COGS for a product business: beginning inventory, plus purchases, production labor, materials and supplies, and other costs, minus ending inventory. Other costs include containers and packaging that are an integral part of the product, freight-in on materials and goods bought for resale, and the direct overhead of the manufacturing operation. Packaging that is not part of the product counts as a shipping or selling expense under the same guidance.

Management reports can go further than the tax return. For pricing and channel decisions, add a contribution view per SKU that layers on outbound freight, 3PL (third-party logistics provider) fees, Amazon and retailer fees, deductions and returns. Keep the definitions the same every month so the trend means something.

  1. Check the BOM (bill of materials) for each SKU against what production actually uses, including scrap and yield loss.
  2. Add the rest of landed cost: freight, duties, insurance and handling from factory to warehouse. The landed cost guide walks through the formula.
  3. Allocate conversion cost: contract manufacturer fees, or in-house labor and overhead per unit.
  4. Layer channel costs for the contribution view: fulfillment, fees, deductions and returns by channel.
  5. Rank SKUs by gross profit dollars and by margin percent. The top and bottom of both lists show where to work first.

How to reduce COGS: the line-by-line teardown

With unit cost broken out, each cost line has its own levers. The table lists the usual places savings come from.

Cost lineWhat it includesWhere savings usually come from
Materials and componentsRaw materials, parts, ingredients and purchased componentsShould-cost models to test quotes, competitive rebids, second sources, and spec changes that keep function and cut cost
PackagingPrimary packaging that is part of the product, inserts and labelsFewer components, standard sizes, lighter materials and combined print runs
ConversionIn-house labor and overhead, or contract manufacturer feesHigher yield, less scrap, fewer changeovers and rebids of contract manufacturing
Inbound freight and dutiesOcean, air and truck freight to the warehouse, customs duties and brokerageConsolidated shipments, mode changes, carrier bids, and a classification and country-of-origin review with a licensed customs broker
Order quantitiesMOQs (minimum order quantities), price breaks and the cash tied up in stockOrder sizes that balance unit price against carrying cost
Scrap, shrink and write-offsProduction scrap, damaged and expired stock, obsolete itemsBetter forecasts, oldest-dated stock picked first, and earlier markdowns on slow movers

Supplier work is often the fastest place to start. Consolidating spend with fewer suppliers raises the company’s volume with each one, which supports better prices and terms. At Mars Inc, my vendor consolidation and centralized procurement work across the brands saved $2.5M a year.

Specification work comes next. A BOM review with engineering and quality often finds parts that can be standardized, materials that can be substituted and features customers do not value. At Tivic Health, I rebuilt the bills of materials with engineering and quality and renegotiated with suppliers, and cost of goods fell 60 percent. On regulated products, such as medical devices, supplier and spec changes go through the quality system before they ship.

How to improve gross margin in manufacturing

In a plant, or at a contract manufacturer, margin depends on how well the line turns materials into good units. The main levers:

  • Yield and scrap. Track first-pass yield, the share of units made right the first time, by line and product. Each point of scrap removed lowers material and labor cost per good unit.
  • Changeovers and run length. Faster changeovers allow smaller batches without losing capacity, and longer runs on steady products spread setup cost over more units.
  • Labor productivity. Balance the line so no station waits on another, and match crew size to the schedule.
  • Overhead absorption. Under standard costing, fixed overhead is spread across planned volume. When actual volume falls short, the unabsorbed overhead lands in COGS as a variance, so the production plan needs to match the sales forecast.
  • Make vs buy. Compare in-house cost per unit, including overhead and capital, with a contract manufacturer’s quote at the same volume and quality.
  • Capacity at the bottleneck. More output at the slowest step spreads fixed cost across more units without adding overhead.

These levers need production data that ties to the books: actual material use, scrap and labor hours by work order. Manufacturing & Kitting work covers capacity plans, should-cost models and supplier changes.

Price, mix and the money that leaks out

Price work starts with the realized price: what the company keeps after every discount and deduction. McKinsey’s pocket price waterfall tracks each step from list price to that number, including on-invoice discounts and off-invoice items such as prompt-payment discounts, co-op advertising allowances, volume rebates, promotions and freight. In one McKinsey example, a lighting supplier kept about half of its list price.

  • Raise prices in steps, by SKU and channel. Start where the brand has the most pricing power, and give retail partners the notice their agreements require.
  • Set discount rules. Decide who can approve a discount, how deep it can go and for which customers.
  • Fix the mix. Point promotions, ad spend and sales effort at the SKUs and channels with the highest gross profit per unit.
  • Cut or reprice the long tail of slow sellers. Drop SKUs that lose money after full cost, unless a profitable customer depends on them.
  • Charge for cost to serve. Add minimum order sizes, freight thresholds or fees for small and rush orders.

Leakage is the last piece. Returns are a large source for consumer brands: in a report released in October 2025 by the NRF (National Retail Federation) and Happy Returns, retailers estimated that 15.8 percent of annual sales would be returned, and 19.3 percent of online sales. Retail deductions, freight that is not passed on, and damaged or expired stock add to it.

Under the IRS guidance, freight-in belongs in COGS and shipping expenses do not, so outbound freight often sits below the gross margin line. It still comes out of every order. UPS bills by dimensional weight when a package is large for its weight, dividing length times width times height by 139 on daily rates, so a smaller carton can cut the billed weight without changing the product. A price increase plan, SKU rationalization and freight cost cuts often run as one program.

Gross margin vs profit margin

Profit margin, or net margin, is what remains after operating costs, interest and taxes, divided by revenue. Gross margin sets the ceiling for it. NYU Stern’s January 2026 data on US public companies shows the gap by industry:

Industry (US public companies, January 2026)Gross marginNet margin
Apparel56.9%3.9%
Beverage (soft)54.7%13.4%
Healthcare products54.0%9.6%
Household products51.0%11.7%
Machinery37.5%10.6%
Food processing23.2%2.8%
All industries37.8%9.7%

To increase profit margin beyond the gross line, work on operating costs: marketing efficiency, fulfillment and customer service cost per order, and overhead that grew faster than revenue. Every point of gross margin gained reaches operating profit as long as operating costs hold, which is why the teardown comes first.

Gross margin improvement ideas: a 90-day plan

  1. Weeks 1 and 2: build the baseline. Gross margin by SKU, customer and channel, from checked BOMs and landed costs.
  2. Weeks 3 and 4: rank the ideas. Size each one in dollars, covering price, mix, suppliers, specs, packaging, freight and returns, and pick the five with the most value and the fastest payback.
  3. Weeks 5 to 8: run the fast ones. Price increases with notice, discount rules, carton changes, supplier rebids and SKU cuts.
  4. Weeks 9 to 12: start the slow ones. Spec changes, second sources, contract manufacturer moves and production changes, each with an owner and a date.
  5. Every month after: track it. Report gross margin by SKU and channel against the plan, and confirm the savings show up in the P&L.

The plan works when finance and operations share one set of SKU numbers and one owner tracks every idea to the P&L. Business Excellence & Profitability follows the same sequence.

How PILTA helps

PILTA helps owners, founders and executive teams clear bottlenecks and production constraints and unlock commercial expansion, then puts proven strategies in place to grow sales, increase margin and scale operations. On margin, senior operators work beside the team to build profit by SKU, customer and channel, tear down cost of goods with should-cost models, renegotiate and consolidate suppliers, cut packaging and freight cost, and set a price increase plan the sales team can carry, across operations, supply chain, sales channels, marketing, finance and systems. The work sits in Business Excellence & Profitability and follows the 4D Method: Diagnose, Design, Develop and Deploy.

Frequently asked questions

How do companies cut cost of goods sold?

They break unit cost into its parts and work each one: rebid materials and components against should-cost models, consolidate suppliers for volume pricing, simplify specs and packaging, cut scrap and improve yield, consolidate inbound freight, and review duty classification. The savings hold when the company tracks cost per unit by SKU every month and ties each change to an owner and a date.

What methods improve margin without increasing prices?

Shift the mix toward higher-margin SKUs and channels, cut cost of goods through supplier and spec work, and stop leakage. Leakage includes discounts no one approved, freight that is not passed on, returns, retail deductions and expired or damaged stock. Tightening discount rules raises the realized price without touching the list price, and it is often the fastest of these methods.

Do you think 50–55% gross margin in ecommerce feels “okay”?

It is in line with US public consumer companies: NYU Stern’s January 2026 data puts average gross margin at 56.9 percent for apparel, 51.0 percent for household products and 54.0 percent for healthcare products. Whether it is enough depends on the costs below gross margin. Ecommerce brands pay for fulfillment, advertising and the cost of handling returns after gross profit, so the real test is contribution margin per order.

How do you handle the psychology of pricing when your COGS suddenly spike 30%+?

Raise prices in steps instead of all at once, starting with the SKUs and channels where demand is least sensitive, and give retail partners the notice their agreements require. Combine the increase with cost work so price does not carry all of it: rebid suppliers, change pack sizes or specs, and consolidate freight. Explain the increase plainly to wholesale customers, with the cost drivers behind it.

How to reduce COGS in retail?

For a retailer, COGS is mostly the cost of goods bought for resale plus freight-in. Lower it by negotiating cost and early-payment discounts, buying direct instead of through a distributor where volume allows, consolidating vendors, combining inbound shipments, and cutting shrink and markdowns with better forecasts. Track landed cost per SKU so freight does not erase a lower invoice price.

How to analyze gross margin?

Calculate revenue minus COGS, divided by revenue, then compare the result by SKU, customer and channel. Review price, sales mix and unit-cost changes separately so the cause of a movement is clear. Check gross profit dollars alongside the percentage, and track outbound freight and other channel costs in a contribution view. PILTA’s team builds the reporting and confirms that improvements reach the P&L.

Sources

Thoughtful experts, building with you, when you need it. Book a free 15-minute call with PILTA, or reach the team at ContactUS@pilta.com.

See if PILTA can help. Get on a call with the PILTA Founder and CEO Ryan or one of our expert executives and strategists. No cost, no obligation, just 15 minutes of your time.

Free assessment

See if PILTA can help.

Get on a call with the PILTA Founder and CEO Ryan or one of our expert executives and strategists. No cost, no obligation, just 15 minutes of your time.

About the author

Ryan Sabia, Founder and CEO of PILTA

Ryan has spent 22+ years from Fortune 500’s like Mars Inc, Toyota and J.P. Morgan to 7+ founder-CEO startups, with 4 public companies, a NASDAQ IPO and 5 M&A deals. At PILTA he helps owners, founders and executive teams clear bottlenecks and production constraints and unlock commercial expansion. LinkedIn