How to choose a 3PL: a buyer-side scorecard and RFP template

Free assessment

See if PILTA can help. A free 15-minute call with the PILTA Founder and CEO Ryan or one of our expert executives and strategists.

To choose a 3PL (third-party logistics provider), start with the brand’s own order data, score every candidate against the same weighted criteria, price each proposal against that same order profile, and settle the contract terms before anyone signs. The pick-and-pack rate is one line on the invoice. Receiving, storage, packaging, returns, shipping and monthly minimums land on the same bill.

Most companies that outsource logistics rate the relationship well. In the 2026 edition of the annual Third-Party Logistics Study, 88 percent of shippers called their 3PL relationships successful. A provider that does not fit the order profile, the channels or the systems costs the business money every month until it moves, and a move means another onboarding.

This guide covers the buyer’s side of the decision: the data to gather, a scorecard to compare providers, the RFP (request for proposal) steps, what each fee costs in 2026 and the contract terms that matter most. The downloadable RFP scorecard follows the same structure.

Quick definitions

3PL (third-party logistics provider): An outside company that receives, stores, picks, packs and ships a brand’s inventory, usually from its own warehouses and on its own software.

RFP (request for proposal): A document that gives every candidate 3PL the same order data and requirements and asks for pricing and answers in the same format.

WMS (warehouse management system): The software a warehouse uses to track inventory by location and to run receiving, picking, packing and shipping.

SLA (service level agreement): The written targets a 3PL commits to, such as order accuracy and ship times, and the remedy when it misses them.

Dock-to-stock time: The time from a shipment’s arrival at the warehouse until its inventory is counted, put away and available to sell.

Start with the brand’s order profile

A 3PL prices and staffs for the work it expects to do. Before contacting anyone, pull 12 months of data so every provider quotes the same business. The order profile covers six things:

  • Orders per month by channel: DTC (direct-to-consumer) parcels, B2B (business-to-business) and retail orders, and Amazon or Walmart.com replenishment, with the peak month called out.
  • Units per order and SKU count: the average and the spread, plus the number of active SKUs (stock keeping units).
  • Inbound pattern: containers, pallets or loose cartons, how often they arrive and whether suppliers send an ASN (advance ship notice).
  • Storage: pallet positions and shelf bins at average and at peak, and how fast each SKU sells through.
  • Product needs: size and weight, temperature, lot and expiry tracking, hazardous materials, kitting, and any FDA registration the product line requires.
  • Returns and destinations: the return rate, and where orders ship, so each warehouse location can be tested against delivery times.

This file becomes the base of the RFP and of the cost model. It also shows which providers to drop early. A warehouse built for single-item parcels is a poor match for pallet orders to retailers with routing guides and EDI (electronic data interchange) requirements.

3PL selection criteria: a buyer-side scorecard

Score every finalist on the same criteria, with weights the team agrees before proposals arrive, so price does not decide by default. The table lists the criteria in the downloadable scorecard, the question behind each one and the evidence to request.

CriterionWhat to askEvidence to request
Product and order fitDo they run accounts with similar products, order types and volumes today?Client references with a similar profile
Channel complianceCan they meet retailer routing guides, EDI and Amazon prep rules?Current retail and Amazon accounts and their chargeback history
Location and transitHow many days does ground shipping take to the main customer regions?A transit-time map from each building
Systems and integrationsWhich WMS runs the building, and does it connect to the store, the sales channels and the ERP (enterprise resource planning) system?A live demo of the client portal and a list of working integrations
Service levelsWhat order accuracy, same-day ship cutoff and dock-to-stock time will they commit to?Twelve months of measured results and the SLA draft
Inventory controlHow often do they cycle count, and how are shrink and damage handled?The count procedure, shrink allowance and claims process
Pricing structureWhich fees apply to this order profile, and which rise each year?A completed pricing sheet in the RFP format
Capacity and peakCan they handle the peak month with room to grow?A peak staffing plan and a space commitment
Account managementWho runs the account day to day, and how are problems escalated?Named contacts and a sample monthly report
Stability and insuranceHow long have they operated, and what liability coverage do they carry?A certificate of insurance and the liability terms

Ask each 3PL for measured results, then compare them with industry figures. Providers in The Fulfillment Advisor’s 2026 survey reported average order-picking accuracy of 99.41 percent and inventory shrinkage of 0.12 percent. The relationship criteria deserve real weight too: in the 2027 Third-Party Logistics Study, shippers ranked trust and open communication as the most important parts of a 3PL partnership, followed by operational excellence and agility.

At Mars Inc, I ran the RFP and onboarding for Wisdom Panel’s new global 3PL; over 12 months, production capacity grew 2,300 percent while service held above 98 percent.

How to run a 3PL RFP, step by step

A 3PL RFP gives every provider the same facts and the same pricing sheet, so the answers can be compared line by line. The usual sequence:

  1. Write the requirements. Turn the order profile into must-haves and nice-to-haves, signed off by operations, finance and customer service.
  2. Build the long list. Collect names from brands with similar products and channels, from the partner lists of the brand’s store and channel software, and from warehouse association directories. Cut it to a short list that fits the product and the channels.
  3. Send the RFP. Include the order profile, the requirements, a standard pricing sheet, the target service levels and a deadline for questions.
  4. Hold one question round. Share every answer with every bidder so the quotes stay comparable.
  5. Model the cost. Run each pricing sheet against the order profile to get a monthly and an annual total, including receiving, storage, packaging, returns, minimums and shipping.
  6. Score and visit. Score the finalists on the scorecard, walk each warehouse during a working shift and call clients with a similar order profile.
  7. Negotiate and plan the move. Settle the contract terms below, then agree an onboarding plan with dates for integration testing, the first inbound receipt and the first live orders.

The cost model in step five is where most of the decision gets made. Two proposals with the same pick fee can end up far apart once storage, packaging and minimums are priced against the brand’s own data. 3PL search, RFP, contract terms and onboarding are part of PILTA’s Supply Chain & Fulfillment work.

3PL pricing: what each fee costs in 2026

3PLs bill each activity separately, so the total depends on the order profile. The averages below come from The Fulfillment Advisor’s 2026 survey of 500 warehousing and fulfillment providers in the United States and Canada.

FeeHow it is billed2026 average
SetupOne time; charged by 55 percent of providers$373.06
Shopping cart integrationOne time, to connect the online store$316.56
ReceivingPer pallet, carton, hour or container$8.75 a pallet, $2.25 a carton, $41.25 an hour, $500 a container
StoragePer pallet per month; reported rates ran from about $6 to $40$19.37
DTC pick and packPer order, first item included$3.21, plus $0.48 for each added item
B2B pick and packPer order, plus a per-item charge$4.86 an order, plus $0.98 an item
Cartons and packagingPer carton, where billed separately (57 percent of providers)$1.46
ReturnsPer return; 87 percent of providers charge for returns$3.56
Account managementPer month; charged by 37 percent of providers$253.33
Monthly minimumPer month, where set; reported minimums ran from $150 to over $1,500$752.08

Shipping sits on top of these fees. Seventy-one percent of providers in the survey charge shipping at cost plus a markup, and the average ground markup was 14.14 percent. Providers also reported an average annual price increase of 3.68 percent, so the contract should state how and when rates change.

Compare proposals on the modeled monthly total for the brand’s own orders. For imported goods, the 3PL bill is one part of the landed cost of each unit; the landed cost calculator adds freight, duty and tariffs to the picture.

Contract terms to settle before signing

The contract decides what happens when volume changes, service slips or the brand decides to leave. Settle these terms before signing:

  • Term and exit. The length of the term, the notice period, the right to terminate for missed service levels, and help moving inventory and data out.
  • Rates and increases. Which rates are fixed, when they can rise and by how much.
  • Minimums. The monthly minimum, when it starts, and whether it waits until every channel is live.
  • Service levels and remedies. Targets for order accuracy, ship times and dock-to-stock time, how each is measured and the credit when the 3PL misses one.
  • Liability for lost or damaged goods. Under the Uniform Commercial Code, a storage agreement can cap the warehouse’s liability, and the owner can ask for a higher valuation at a higher rate (UCC 7-204). Match the cap to the value of the inventory and insure any gap.
  • Warehouse lien. A warehouse has a lien on stored goods for unpaid charges (UCC 7-209). Agree in writing how billing disputes are resolved so inventory keeps shipping while one is open.
  • Counts and shrink. How often inventory is counted, the shrink allowance and how losses are reimbursed.
  • Data access. Real-time inventory and order data, and the right to export it.

Onboarding and the monthly scorecard

Onboarding is where integrations, inbound receipts and the first invoices get tested. A written plan names an owner on each side, a test window for every integration and a go-live date for each channel. Keep the old fulfillment option running until the new 3PL has shipped clean orders on every channel.

After go-live, review the same criteria each month: order accuracy, on-time shipping, dock-to-stock time, inventory accuracy, shrink and billing accuracy. Audit invoices line by line against the contract rates, and hold a quarterly business review with the 3PL’s account lead. At Tivic Health, I set up 24-hour fulfillment with EDI through a move to an FDA-registered 3PL.

Download the 3PL RFP scorecard (Excel). Free, no sign-up.

How PILTA helps

PILTA helps owners, founders and executive teams clear the bottlenecks and production constraints that hold back growth and unlock commercial expansion, then puts proven strategies in place to grow sales, increase margin and scale operations. On a 3PL decision, senior operators build the order profile, run the RFP and the cost model, negotiate the contract and manage onboarding beside your team, then keep the monthly scorecard and billing audits running. The work sits within Supply Chain & Fulfillment and follows the 4D Method: Diagnose, Design, Develop, Deploy.

Frequently asked questions

How much does a 3PL cost?

In The Fulfillment Advisor’s 2026 survey of 500 providers, the average was $3.21 to pick and pack a one-item consumer order, $19.37 per pallet per month for storage, $8.75 to receive a pallet and $3.56 per return. Providers that set a monthly minimum averaged $752.08. Shipping is billed on top, most often at cost plus a markup, so the real number comes from pricing each proposal against the brand’s own orders.

What is a 3PL RFP?

A 3PL RFP (request for proposal) is the document a brand sends to candidate 3PLs to get proposals it can compare. It holds the order profile, the requirements, a standard pricing sheet, the target service levels and the timeline. Because every bidder prices the same data on the same sheet, the brand can model each proposal’s monthly cost and score the answers side by side.

How do I find a good 3PL company?

Start with referrals and fit. Ask brands with similar products and channels which 3PLs they use, check the partner lists of the store and channel software the brand runs, and search warehouse association directories. Cut the list to providers that already ship similar orders, send each the same RFP, and visit the finalists during a working shift before choosing.

How to pick the best 3PL?

Pick the best fit for the brand’s order profile, because no single 3PL is best for every brand. Agree weights before proposals arrive, then score each finalist on product fit, channels, location, systems, service levels, pricing and contract terms. Compare modeled monthly totals for the brand’s own orders, and let references with a similar profile and a site visit settle close calls.

How to evaluate 3PL?

Evaluate a 3PL every month against the targets in its contract: order accuracy, on-time shipping, dock-to-stock time, inventory accuracy, shrink and billing accuracy. Compare the results with industry figures; providers in The Fulfillment Advisor’s 2026 survey averaged 99.41 percent picking accuracy and 0.12 percent shrinkage. Audit invoices against contract rates and review the scorecard with the 3PL’s account lead each quarter.

Is 3PL worth it?

A 3PL is usually worth it once packing orders in-house takes more time and space than the team can spare, or when the brand needs faster delivery from more locations. Compare its full cost with the current setup on the same orders: receiving, storage, pick and pack, packaging, returns, minimums and shipping. Check systems, channel requirements and measured service before deciding. PILTA’s team builds that comparison, runs the selection process and manages onboarding.

Sources

Thoughtful experts, building with you, when you need it. Book a free 15-minute call with PILTA, or reach the team at ContactUS@pilta.com.

See if PILTA can help. Get on a call with the PILTA Founder and CEO Ryan or one of our expert executives and strategists. No cost, no obligation, just 15 minutes of your time.

Free assessment

See if PILTA can help.

Get on a call with the PILTA Founder and CEO Ryan or one of our expert executives and strategists. No cost, no obligation, just 15 minutes of your time.

About the author

Ryan Sabia, Founder and CEO of PILTA

Ryan has spent 22+ years from Fortune 500’s like Mars Inc, Toyota and J.P. Morgan to 7+ founder-CEO startups, with 4 public companies, a NASDAQ IPO and 5 M&A deals. At PILTA he helps owners, founders and executive teams clear bottlenecks and production constraints and unlock commercial expansion. LinkedIn